Binky Betsy (cookie77) wrote in binky_betsy,
Binky Betsy

How about that NYE date, anyway?

You know, the infamous NYE party where we find out that Anthony is engaged, while still thought-bubbling all over Liz. But look at this strip The one right before the Jelly high-five strip. "I never stopped thinking about you, Liz," and he's engaged? ETA: Fixed link!

Plus which, Liz's reactions don't quite ring true. She seems so happy when Ant tells her he's engaged ...but that's not quite consistent with her ants-in-pants joy at seeing "the sweet boy I dated in high school." When I first saw that (back when I took for granted that Pattersons would have normal responses and use earth-logic), I thought Liz's "happiness" was her trying to save face, and in fact, she was hardly overjoyed. Really, if a guy I used to date asked me to a formal event and sprung it on me at midnight on NYE that he was engaged to someone else, I'd be anything from mildly annoyed to super-pissed. Depending on how much I had invested in him. I can't really see myself being triangle-mouthed with happiness if a guy who'd been acting like a DATE, not a FRIEND, all night, capped off the evening by telling me he was engaged. And if he'd told me beforehand, I might not go, also depending on circumstances. Like in this instance, never having met the fiancee, thus not wanting her to get a wrong idea. And if Ant's reason for not telling Liz beforehand was that she might not go, if that's a risk he doesn't want to take, he shouldn't be engaged.

And as I think I've said before, I took this final panel totally the wrong way. I thought Ant looked stricken because he intended this to be his and Liz's last embrace ever. Sad to be leaving her in the past, but it had to be. I mean, he does say goodbye. It just doesn't have to be tragic.

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.